Popular reviews for Red (Taylor’s Version):
Pitchfork‘s Red (Taylor’s Version) review summary:
Pitchfork‘s album score: 8.5
The review of Red (Taylor’s Version) by Taylor Swift is largely positive, emphasizing the album’s significance both as a commercial endeavor and an artistic statement.
Swift’s re-recording of Red is seen as a strategic move to regain control over her music, and it’s noted for its appeal to her dedicated fan base, the Swifties. The album Red, originally released in 2012, is described as a pivotal work in Swift’s career, marking a transition from country to pop and showcasing some of her best lyrical work.
The re-recorded album includes 30 songs, featuring both subtle and significant changes from the original. Notable differences include new collaborations with artists like Phoebe Bridgers and Chris Stapleton, and “vault” tracks that were either previously released by other artists or are being heard for the first time. The reviewer highlights the extended cut of “All Too Well” as particularly anticipated, despite some of its added verses not being as impactful as the original.
While acknowledging that not all the new material is of equal quality, the review praises tracks like “Nothing New,” featuring Bridgers, for its introspective examination of the music industry’s treatment of young women. The collaboration with Bridgers is seen as significant, showcasing a more inclusive approach by Swift.
The review also touches on the mixed quality of tracks on “Red,” acknowledging some as masterpieces while others as less impressive. Overall, the re-recording is appreciated for revisiting Swift’s past work comprehensively, allowing her to reclaim and reinterpret her music, and it’s seen as a testament to her resilience and ability to connect with her audience. The reviewer concludes that Swift’s revisitation of her past is a necessary step toward her future, both artistically and in terms of gaining control over her music.
Read Pitchfork‘s full Red (Taylor’s Version) review.
Rolling Stone’s Red (Taylor’s Version) review summary
Red (Taylor’s Version) is highly praised in the review for not only meeting but exceeding expectations, particularly with the extended 10-minute version of “All Too Well.” The reviewer applauds Taylor Swift for transforming her 2012 album into an even more extensive and emotionally resonant experience. The new version is described as bigger, glossier, and deeper, successfully expanding upon Swift’s most ambitious pop manifesto.
The album, part of Swift’s project to remake her old albums, is noted for its faithful adherence to the original while introducing new elements. The reviewer highlights the “All Too Well (Original Version)” as a standout, delving deeper into Swift’s storytelling prowess. The new material, including tracks “Nothing New” with Phoebe Bridgers and “I Bet You Think About Me” with Chris Stapleton, is celebrated for adding depth and variety to the album. Other tracks like “Ronan,” a charity single from 2012, and Swift’s versions of songs she had given to other artists like “Better Man” and “Babe,” are also appreciated for their inclusion.
The reviewer expresses admiration for Swift’s ability to revisit her past work with such finesse, noting that her adult voice adds new power to the songs. The new Red is seen not just as a nostalgic journey but as a testament to Swift’s growth as an artist. Despite the album’s retrospective nature, it also excites anticipation for Swift’s future endeavors. The review concludes by highlighting Swift’s unique position in the music industry, capable of successfully revisiting past works while actively shaping her future artistic trajectory.
Read Rolling Stone‘s full Red (Taylor’s Version) review.
Variety’s Red (Taylor’s Version) review summary
In the review of Red (Taylor’s Version), the re-recording of Taylor Swift’s 2012 album is highly praised, particularly for the extended 10-minute version of “All Too Well.” The reviewer celebrates Swift’s skill in retelling and expanding upon the emotional depth of her original songs, making them even more impactful. This re-release, part of Swift’s project to regain control over her discography, includes nine previously unrecorded songs, which are eagerly anticipated by fans and critics alike.
The new material is highlighted for its quality and diversity, with collaborations such as “Nothing New” featuring Phoebe Bridgers, and “I Bet You Think About Me” with Chris Stapleton, receiving particular acclaim. These additional songs add new layers to the album, showcasing Swift’s growth as a songwriter and artist. The reviewer notes the seamless blend of old and new, with the original album’s themes of heartbreak and personal narrative being enhanced by the fresh content.
The review also acknowledges the challenge of remaking an already iconic album, but Swift is commended for her ability to reinterpret her work while staying true to the essence of the original Red. The re-recorded tracks are seen as meticulously crafted, with Swift’s collaborators receiving praise for their contributions. The overall sentiment is that Red (Taylor’s Version) not only revisits Swift’s past work but elevates it, affirming her status as a top-tier singer-songwriter and the enduring relevance of her music.
Read Variety‘s full Red (Taylor’s Version) review.
What the Swifties say
We’ve heard from the critics, but what do Swifties think of Red (Taylor’s Version)?
Google audience reviews
According to over 1,200 Google audience reviews, Swifties give Red (Taylor’s Version) a resounding 5-star rating.
Reddit reviews
There may be no better way to get Swifties’ real opinions than checking Reddit. Here’s a mega-thread talking all things Red (Taylor’s Version):
Taypedia 